Packers Morning Buzz: Brett Favre or Aaron Rodgers? Picking a 'franchise quarterback'

Stu Courtney
Packers News
View Comments

Welcome to your Morning Buzz, rounding up news and views regarding the Green Bay Packers from around the web and here at

We'll start with Ali Bhanpuri of asking who rates as the best quarterback in the history of each NFC North team. One caveat: The assessment includes only statistics from 1967 onward (when the common draft era between the NFL and AFL began), meaning Bart Starr is out of the running for the Packers.

So the choice for the Packers' "franchise quarterback" comes down to the two obvious choices. Here's why Bhanpuri favors Brett Favre over Aaron Rodgers:

Rodgers might very well overtake Favre by the time his career is over, but for right now, No. 4 remains the Packers' best QB1 of the common era. Favre currently has more MVPs, first-team All-Pros, Packers starts and Pro Bowlselections than Rodgers -- and he owns a higher regular-season winning percentage. Favre was the epitome of durability, starting 275 consecutive games (including playoffs) for the Pack and posting only one losing record in 16 seasons. And while Rodgers has set the NFL world on fire with multiple successful Hail Mary attempts, Favre finished his Packers career with nearly twice as many game-winning drives (37 to 20) as Rodgers. Look, nearly every fan base would happily claim either of these guys as their best franchise QB of all time (I know Bears fans would), and Rodgers has the potential to finish his NFL career as a top-five QB of all time. But that's looking into the future. Based on the totality of their Packer achievements to this point, Favre's epic level of excellence over such an extended period of time wins out.

Green Bay Packers legend Brett Favre hugs quarterback Aaron Rodgers after Favre's halftime ceremony on Thanksgiving at Lambeau Field.

The story also looks at each team's biggest QB bust, and for the Packers it's Randy Wright:

Hard to feel too bad for a fan base that lucked out with Starr, Favre and Rodgers at quarterback. But the Packers faithful who cheered on the Green Bay teams of the mid-'80s did endure a five-year interval during which a sixth-round draft pick out of Wisconsin lost 25 of his 32 starts, including 12 in the 1986 season. That quarterback would finish his Packers career (and his run in the NFL, for that matter) with a 53.8 completion percentage, a 31:57 TD-to-INT ratio and a 61.4 passer rating. His name is Randy Wright. Bears, Lions and Vikings supporters must never let his legacy fade.

You can read the entire story here:

The Packers provide a glimpse of their red-zone offense during Wednesday's open OTA:

Matt LaFleur and Davante Adams share personal reflections on Bart Starr; how Aaron Jones reduced his body fat:

Adams tells the humorous tale of how he learned about Starr's iconic status upon being drafted by Green Bay:

Photographer Adam Wesley has all the action from Wednesday's OTA:

Favre joined the Rich Eisen Show on Tuesday to talk about his relationship with Starr:

Fans in Green Bay pay their respects at the Starr statue outside the Resch Center:

And finally: A familiar Packers name makes yet another All-Under-25 team, this one from Marc Sessler of

Defensive tackle: Kenny Clark, Green Bay Packers (23 as of Sept. 5). More people should know Clark, the somewhat anonymous Green Bay anchor who played well against the run and pass in 2018. Tampa's Vita Vea (24) deserves a mention here, too, while Chris Jones (turning 25 in July), Leonard Williams (turning 25 in June), DeForest Buckner (25) and Sheldon Rankins (25) all missed out due to age.

You can see the entire team here:

Contact Stu Courtney at (920) 431-8377 or Follow him on Twitter at @stucourt

View Comments